|
I was recently informed that
occasionally the Prophet (saw), whilst
travelling, prayed the full Salah rather than
the two Rak’aat. Is this true and will the Salah
be valid?
It is not permissible for a
traveller to perform the full prayer i.e. 4
Rakats. Almighty Allāh has instructed the
traveller to perform Qasr and this is obligatory
without choice. There are certain traditions
that suggest that the Prophet (saw) performed
the full 4 Rak`aat occasionally. (See Dārqutnī
1:242, Bayhaqī 3:142) However, all these
traditions are related by unreliable narrators.
(Zaadul-Ma`ād, 1:464) If someone however
performs 4 Rak`aat, then according to the Hanafi
school of thought, his Salāh will only be valid
if he performs Sajdatus-Sahw in which case the
extra 2 Rak`aat will be regarded as Nafl. (Raddul-Muhtār)
 |